|
With the inclusion
of a
consumer-oriented
version of Microsoft
Windows XP Home
there has been some
confusion
surrounding the
differences between
this product
compared to its more
upscale sibling,
Microsoft Windows XP
Professional
Edition.
Microsoft Windows XP
Home Edition is not
a managed Operating
System. It's
optimized for the
consumer market &
not meant for multi
user networking.
Microsoft Windows XP
Home Edition
Overview
Microsoft Windows XP
Home Edition
includes a number of
enhancements over
Microsoft Windows
2000 Professional.
These include:
-
Improved
software
(application)
and hardware
compatibility
-
Simplified
security
-
Simplified
log-on featuring
new "welcome"
screen
-
Fast user
switching
-
A new user
interface
featuring
context-sensitive,
task-oriented
Web views
-
Enhanced support
for digital
media (movies,
pictures, music)
-
DirectX 8.1
multimedia
libraries for
gaming
Microsoft Windows XP
Professional
Edition: Superset of
Home Edition
At its most basic
level, Microsoft
Windows XP
Professional is a
business and power
user oriented
superset of Home
Edition. Because
this orientation, it
includes features
that wouldn't be
appropriate, or
would be too
complex, for the
typical home user.
The most obvious
difference is
security, which is
vastly simplified in
Home Edition. Each
interactive user in
XP Home is assumed
to be a member of
the Owners local
group, which is the
Microsoft Windows XP
equivalent of the
Microsoft Windows
2000 Administrator
account: This means
that anyone who logs
on to a Home Edition
machine has full
control. Likewise,
the Backup
Operators, Power
Users, and
Replicator groups
from Microsoft
Windows XP 2000/XP
Pro are missing from
Home Edition, and a
new group, called
Restricted Users, is
added. Hidden
administrative
shares (C$, etc.)
are also unavailable
in Home Edition.
"Professional
Edition is a strict
superset of Home
Edition," confirmed
Chris Jones, Vice
President of the
Microsoft Windows XP
Client Group.
"Everything you can
do in Home Edition,
you can do in Pro.
So we do think there
are home users who
will buy Pro."
Jones' distinction
is a good one: With
Microsoft Windows
XP, the Professional
Edition is finally a
superset of all the
desktop clients that
came before
(Microsoft Windows
XP Me and Microsoft
Windows XP 2000
Professional) as
well as of its new
sibling. So when
discussing the
differences between
the editions, it's
best to simply
describe those
features in Pro that
you can't get in
Home Edition.
Pro features that
aren't in Microsoft
Windows XP Home
Edition
Power user
-
Remote Desktop -
All versions of
Microsoft
Windows XP
-including Home
Edition--support
Remote
Assistance,
which is an
assisted support
technology that
allows a help
desk or system
administrator to
remotely connect
to a client
desktop for
troubleshooting
purposes. But
Only Microsoft
Windows XP
Professional
supports the new
Remote Desktop
feature, which
is a
single-session
version of
Terminal
Services with
two obvious
uses: Mobile
professionals
who need to
remotely access
their corporate
desktop, and
remote
administration
of clients on a
network. You can
access a
Microsoft
Windows XP XP
Remote Desktop
from any OS that
supports a
Terminal
Services client
(such as
Microsoft
Windows XP 98
and,
interestingly XP
Home). XP Home
can act as the
client in a
Remote Desktop
session; only
Pro can be the
server.
-
Multi-processor
support -
Microsoft
Windows XP Pro
supports up to
two
microprocessors,
while Home
Edition supports
only one.
-
Automated System
Recovery (ASR) -
In a somewhat
controversial
move, Microsoft
has removed the
Backup utility
from the default
Microsoft
Windows XP XP
Home Edition,
though it is
available as an
optional
installation if
you can find it
on the CD-ROM
(hint: it's in
the /valueadd
folder). The
reason for this
the integration
of Microsoft's
new Automated
System Recovery
(ASR) tool into
Backup. In Pro,
ASR will help
recover a system
from a
catastrophic
error, such as
one that renders
the system
unbootable.
ASR-enabled
backups are
triggerable from
XP Setup,
allowing you to
return your
system to its
previous state,
even if the hard
drive dies and
has to be
replaced. Unlike
consumer-oriented
features such as
System Restore,
ASR is not
automatic: It
must manually be
enabled from
within the
Backup utility
in Microsoft
Windows XP XP
Pro. In any
event, while
there is a
Backup utility
available for
Home Edition,
you cannot use
ASR, even though
mentions of this
feature still
exist in the UI.
Confusing? Yes.
But it's better
than no Backup
at all, which
was the original
plan.
-
Dynamic Disk
Support -
Microsoft
Windows XP XP
Professional
(like its
Microsoft
Windows XP 2000
equivalent)
supports dynamic
disks, but Home
Edition does not
(instead, HE
supports only
the standard
Simple Disk
type). Dynamic
disks are not
usable with any
OS other than
Microsoft
Windows XP 2000
or Microsoft
Windows XP XP
Pro, and they
cannot be used
on portable
computers.
Likewise, Home
Edition does not
include the
Logical Disk
Manager.
-
Fax - Home
Edition has no
integrated fax
functionality
out of the box,
though it is an
option you can
install from the
XP Home CD.
-
Internet
Information
Services/Personal
Web Server -
Home Edition
does not include
the IIS Web
server 5.1
software found
in Pro.
Security
-
Encrypting File
System -
Microsoft
Windows XP
Professional
supports the
Encrypting File
System (EFS),
which allows you
encrypt
individual files
or folders for
local security (EFS
is not enabled
over a network).
EFS-protected
files and
folders allows
users to protect
sensitive
documents from
other users.
-
File-level
access control -
Any user with
Administrator
privileges can
limit access to
certain network
resources, such
as servers,
directories, and
files, using
access control
lists. Only
Microsoft
Windows XP XP
Professional
supports
file-level
access control,
mostly because
this feature is
typically
implemented
through Group
Policy Objects,
which are also
not available in
Home Edition.
-
"C2"
certification -
Microsoft will
attempt to have
Microsoft
Windows XP
Professional
certified with
the "C2"
security
designation, a
largely
irrelevant
status, but one
which will not
be afforded to
Home Edition.
Management
-
Domain
membership -
Home Edition
cannot be used
to logon to an
Active Directory
domain. For
obvious reasons,
the Domain
Wizard is also
missing in Home
Edition.
-
Group Policy -
Since Home
Edition cannot
be used to logon
to an Active
Directory
domain, Group
Policy--whereby
applications,
network
resources, and
operating
systems are
administered for
domain users--is
not supported
either.
-
IntelliMirror -
Microsoft lumps
a wide range of
semi-related
change and
configuration
management
technologies
under the
IntelliMirror
umbrella, and
none of these
features are
supported in the
consumer
oriented Home
Edition.
IntelliMirror
capabilities
include user
data management;
centrally-managed
software
installation,
repair,
updating, and
removal; user
settings
management; and
Remote
Installation
Services (RIS),
which allows
administrators
to remotely
install the OS
on client
systems.
-
Roaming profiles
- This feature
allows users to
logon to any
computer in an
Active Directory
network and
automatically
receive their
customized
settings. It is
not available in
Home Edition,
which cannot
logon to an
Active Directory
domain.
Corporate
deployment
-
Multi-language
support - Only
Microsoft
Windows XP
Professional
will ship in a
Multi-Language
version or
support multiple
languages in a
single install.
-
Sysprep support
- Microsoft
Windows XP Pro
will support the
System
Preparation (Sysprep)
utility, while
Home Edition
will not.
-
RIS support -
See the
IntelliMirror
heading in the
previous
section; Home
Edition does not
support RIS
deployments.
64-bit Edition
-
Microsoft is
shipping a
64-bit version
of Microsoft
Windows XP for
Intel Itanium
systems that
mirrors the
Professional
Edition
feature-set.
Networking
features
The
following
networking
features are not
included in Home
Edition:
-
The user
interface for
IPSecurity (IPSec)
-
SNMP
-
Simple TCP/IP
services
-
SAP Agent
-
Client Service
for NetWare
-
Network Monitor
-
Multiple Roaming
feature
User interface
features
Microsoft
Windows XP Home
Edition has some
different
default settings
that affect the
user interface.
For example,
Guest logon is
on by default in
Home, but off in
Pro. The Address
bar in Explorer
Microsoft
Windows XP is on
in Pro by
default, but off
in Home. During
the beta period,
Microsoft had
intended to use
a
business-oriented
shell theme
("Professional")
by default in
Pro and the
"Luna" consumer
theme in Home
Edition. But
feedback from
corporate users
suggested that
everyone liked
the
consumer-oriented
Luna theme
better, and
development of
the Professional
theme was
cancelled. Other
user interface
features that
are present in
Pro but not Home
include:
-
Client-side
caching
-
Administrative
Tools option on
the Start menu
(a subset of the
Admin tools are
still present in
Home, however).
It's also worth
mentioning that Home
Edition will support
upgrades from
Microsoft Windows XP
98, 98 SE, and
Millennium Edition
(Me), but not from
Microsoft Windows XP
95, NT 4.0
Workstation, or
Microsoft Windows XP
2000 Professional.
You can upgrade from
Microsoft Windows XP
98, 98 SE,
Millennium Edition
(Me), Microsoft
Windows XP NT 4.0
Workstation, or
Microsoft Windows XP
2000 Professional to
Microsoft Windows XP
Professional. See my
article on
What to Expect from
Microsoft Windows XP
XP for more
information.
Deciding which
edition to buy is
simple: Peruse the
above list and
decide whether you
can live without any
of these features.
If you can't, then
you're going to want
to get Professional.
Otherwise, save $100
and get Home
Edition. Note that
Microsoft is
offering a
less-expensive
Professional
"Step-Up" upgrade
for Home users that
wish to move to
Microsoft Windows XP
Professional.
|